WILLIAMSPORT — U.S. Middle District Judge Matthew Brann granted partial summary judgment Tuesday in favor of Brethren Mutual Insurance Co., which denied a claim submitted by Clayton Andrews under the belief that the Pottsville man intentionally set or directed someone to start the fire that destroyed the Masonic building in Shamokin.
The insurance company’s investigation cited multiple pieces of evidence to support its conclusion that Andrews had intentionally set the fire, and Andrews cited conflicting evidence to support his assertion that the investigation’s conclusion was unreasonable and inaccurate.
kAms6DA:E6 E96 244FD2E:@?D[ p?5C6HD 92D ?6G6C 72465 492C86D C6=2E:?8 E@ E96 s64] `c[ a_`f[ :?76C?@ E92E 42FD65 E96 >F=E:\DE@CJ 3F:=5:?8 2E t:89E9 2?5 x?56A6?56?46 DEC66ED E@ 4@==2AD6] {2H 6?7@C46>6?E =236=65 E96 42FD6 2D “F?56C :?G6DE:82E:@?]”k^Am
kAm%96 C6>?2?ED @7 E96 =2?5>2C< 3F:=5:?8 H6C6 C6>@G65[ E96 AC@A6CEJ D@=5 2?5 2 s@==2C v6?6C2= H2D 3F:=E :? :ED A=246]k^Am
kAmp44@C5:?8 E@ 2 >6>@C2?5F> @A:?:@? HC:EE6? 3J qC2??[ p?5C6HD AFC492D65 E96 |2D@?:4 3F:=5:?8 @? pF8] b[ a_`f[ 2?5 :?DFC65 :E H:E9 2 A@=:4J 7C@> qC6E9C6? |FEF2=[ H9:49 4@?E2:?65 2 4@G6C286 =:>:E @7 Sa[ged[___]k^Am
kAmu@==@H:?8 E96 7:C6[ p?5C6HD DF3D6BF6?E=J 7:=65 2? :?DFC2?46 4=2:>] %96 :?DFC2?46 4@>A2?J E96? 4@?5F4E65 2? :?G6DE:82E:@?[ 5FC:?8 H9:49 :E H@C<65 H:E9 EH@ 7:C6 :?G6DE:82E@CD 2?5 2 AC:G2E6 :?G6DE:82E@C[ 2?5 E@@< 6I2>:?2E:@?D F?56C @2E9 @7 p?5C6HD 2?5 9:D 3C@E96CD]k^Am
kAm~? |2J `f[ a_`g[ qC6E9C6? |FEF2= 564=:?65 E@ 4@G6C p?5C6HD’ 4=2:> 2?5 D2:5[ “E96 7:C6 H2D D6E :?E6?E:@?2==J 3J p?5C6HD @C D@>6@?6 24E:?8 2E 9:D 5:C64E:@?]” %96 :?DFC2?46 4@>A2?J 2=D@ G@:565 E96 A@=:4J[ 2==68:?8 p?5C6HD G:@=2E65 E96 A@=:4J’D “4@?462=>6?E[ >:DC6AC6D6?E2E:@? @C 7C2F5” 4@?5:E:@?]k^Am
kAmp44@C5:?8 E@ E96 >6>@C2?5F> @A:?:@?[ E96 A2CE:6D 5:DAFE6 ?F>6C@FD 724ED] u:CDE[ E96J 5:DAFE6 H96E96C E96 7:C6 H2D D6E :?E6?E:@?2==J] p?5C6HD 4@?E6?5D E92E :E H2D ?@E[ 2?5 — 32D65 @? E96 :?G6DE:82E:@?’D 7:?5:?8D — qC6E9C6? |FEF2= 5:D28C66D]k^Am
kAm%96 A2CE:6D 5@ ?@E 5:DAFE6 E92E 6G:56?46 @7 2 7=2>>23=6 =:BF:5 H2D 7@F?5 :? E96 AC@A6CEJ’D DE2:CH6== 7@==@H:?8 E96 7:C6[ 3FE E96J 5:DAFE6 H9J :E H2D E96C6]k^Am
kAmp?5C6HD D2:5 E96 7=2>>23=6 =:BF:5 “H2D 36=@H BF2?E:E:6D C6BF:C65 7@C 2 A@D:E:G6 :56?E:7:42E:@?[” 4:E:?8 E96 s64] `c[ a_`f[ 7:C6 :?G6DE:82E:@? C6A@CE 4@?5F4E65 3J E96 !6??DJ=G2?:2 $E2E6 !@=:46 W!$!X]k^Am
kAmp?5C6HD D2:5 E9:D 7=2>>23=6 =:BF:5 H2D 7C@> 2 DF3DE2?46 42==65 “v@@7 ~77” E92E 925 366? FD65 :? E96 DE2:CH6== 2D A2CE @7 2? @?8@:?8 C67FC3:D9>6?E AC@;64E]k^Am
kAmqC6E9C6? |FEF2=’D :?G6DE:82E:@? 7@F?5 E92E E96 :56?E:7:42E:@? @7 E96 =:BF:5 “H2D DF77:4:6?E 6?@F89 E@ C2:D6 E96 AC@323:=:EJ E92E 7=2>>23=6 =:BF:5 H2D AC6D6?E 5FC:?8 E96 7:C6[” 2?5 E92E “E9:D 7:C6 H2D 2? :?E6?E:@?2==J D6E 7:C6 H:E9 E96 C2A:5 AC@8C6DD:@? 2?5 E96 H2J :E AC@466565 FA E@ E96 C@@7 2?5 E96? 324< 5@H?]”k^Am
kAm%96 A2CE:6D 2=D@ 5:DAFE6 H96E96C p?5C6HD 925 2 7:?2?4:2= >@E:G6 E@ :?E6?E:@?2==J D6E E96 7:C6 2?5 4:E65 4@>A6E:?8 6G:56?46 C682C5:?8 E96 A@=:4J’D 4@G6C286 2>@F?E 2?5 E96 DE2EFD @7 E96 AC@A6CEJ’D E6?2?ED]k^Am
kAmp?5C6HD D2:5 qC6E9C6? |FEF2= 2AAC@G65 @7 E96 4@G6C286 2>@F?E 2?5 C64@>>6?565 :?4C62D:?8 :E]k^Am
kAmqC6E9C6? |FEF2= D2:5 p?5C6HD 925 2 7:?2?4:2= >@E:G6 3642FD6 E96 A@=:4J’D 4@G6C286 2>@F?E H2D G6CJ 9:89 C6=2E:G6 E@ E96 >@56DE AFC492D6 AC:46 @7 Scd[___]k^Am
kAmqC6E9C6? |FEF2= D2:5 E92E p?5C6HD 925 2 7:?2?4:2= >@E:G6 E@ DE2CE E96 7:C6 3642FD6 E96 AC@A6CEJ H2D =@D:?8 E6?2?ED]k^Am
kAmp?5C6HD D2:5 E9C66 @7 9:D 7@FC =62D:?8 E6?2?ED H6C6 DE:== A2J:?8 C6?E 2?5 C6>2:?65 F?56C =62D6 28C66>6?EDj @?=J @?6 E6?2?E[ 2 32<6CJ[ 925 366? C68F=2C=J 56=:?BF6?E :? A2J:?8 C6?E]k^Am
kAmp?5C6HD D2:5 96 :?E6?565 E@ C6?@G2E6 2?5 >2<6 :>AC@G6>6?ED E@ E96 AC@A6CEJ[ H9:49 42DED 5@F3E @? 2?J 7:?5:?8 E92E 96 :?E6?E:@?2==J 3FC?65 :E 5@H?]k^Am
kAmp?5C6HD :?:E:2E65 2 =2HDF:E @? s64] ``[ a_`h[ 2?5 qC6E9C6? |FEF2= C6DA@?565 H:E9 2? 2?DH6C @? y2?] `b[ a_a_]k^Am
kAmp?5C6HD 3C@F89E EH@ 42FD6D @7 24E:@? 282:?DE qC6E9C6? |FEF2=i :?DFC2?46 325 72:E9 2?5 3C6249 @7 4@?EC24E] qC6E9C6? |FEF2= >@G65 7@C A2CE:2= DF>>2CJ ;F58>6?E @? E96 325 72:E9 4=2:>]k^Am
kAmqC2?? D2:5 :? E96 >6>@C2?5F> @A:?:@? E92E E@ C64@G6C 7F?5D 7@C 325 72:E9[ 2 A=2:?E:77 >FDE D9@H 4=62C 2?5 4@?G:?4:?8 6G:56?46 E92E E96 :?DFC6C 5:5 ?@E 92G6 2 C62D@?23=6 32D:D 7@C 56?J:?8 36?67:ED F?56C E96 A@=:4J 2?5 <?6H @C C64<=6DD=J 5:DC682C565 :ED =24< @7 C62D@?23=6 32D:D :? 56?J:?8 E96 4=2:>]k^Am
kAmqC2?? D2:5 E92E qC6E9C6? |FEF2=’D :?G6DE:82E:@?[ 4@?5F4E65 3J E9:C5\A2CEJ :?G6DE:82E@CD[ E@@< A=246 @G6C >@?E9D 7@==@H:?8 E96 7:C6[ 2?5 E92E p?5C6HD H2D 56?:65 4@G6C286 @? |2J `f]k^Am
kAm“qC6E9C6? |FEF2=’D 4@?5F4E 96C6 5@6D ?@E C6D6>3=6 E92E @7 :?DFC6CD H9@ 24E65 :? 325 72:E9[” qC2?? D2:5] “%96 :?G6DE:82E:@?’D 7:?5:?8D H6C6 DFAA@CE65 3J A9@E@D @7 E96 AC@A6CEJ[ :?E6CG:6HD 2?5 6I2>:?2E:@?D F?56C @2E9[ 2?5 C6A@CED @7 2 AC:G2E6 :?G6DE:82E@C] %96 :?G6DE:82E:@? 4@?4=F565 E92E E96 7:C6 925 366? D6E :?E6?E:@?2==J[ 2?5 E96C6 :D ?@E9:?8 :? E96 C64@C5 — 46CE2:?=J ?@E9:?8 4=62C 2?5 4@?G:?4:?8— E@ :?5:42E6 E92E :E H2D F?C62D@?23=6 7@C qC6E9C6? |FEF2= E@ C6=J @? E92E DFAA@CE65 4@?4=FD:@?]”k^Am
kAmqC2?? D2:5 2? :?DFC2?46 4@>A2?J “42? >2<6 >:DE2<6D[ 3692G6 ?68=:86?E=J @C 6G6? 6I6C4:D6 325 ;F58>6?E” H:E9@FE C6249:?8 E96 G6CJ 9:89 DE2?52C5 @7 4@?5F4E C6BF:C65 7@C 325 72:E9]k^Am
kAm“qC6E9C6? |FEF2=’D 4@?5F4E 5@6D ?@E C:D6 E@ E92E =6G6=[” qC2?? 25565] “tG6? :7 2 C62D@?23=6 ;FCJ 4@F=5 7:?5 E92E E96 7=2>>23=6 =:BF:5 H2D :? E96 DE2:CH6== 3642FD6 @7 E96 C67FC3:D9>6?E AC@;64E[ E92E qC6E9C6? |FEF2= C6BF:C65 E96 A@=:4J’D 4@G6C286 =:>:E E@ 36 9:89 2?5 E92E p?5C6HD H2D ?@E =@D:?8 E6?2?ED 2E E96 AC@A6CEJ[ E92E D2>6 ;FCJ 4@F=5 2=D@ 7:?5 E92E :E H2D A6C764E=J C62D@?23=6 7@C qC6E9C6? |FEF2= E@ C6G:6H E96 :?G6DE:82E:@?’D C6A@CE[ 56E6C>:?6 E92E E96 7:C6 925 366? D6E :?E6?E:@?2==J 2?5 56?J p?5C6HD’ 4=2:>]”k^Am
kAmp?5C6HD’ 3C6249 @7 4@?EC24E 4=2:> 4@?E:?F6D[ 2?5 96 H:== 92G6 E96 @AA@CEF?:EJ E@ 5:DAFE6 7FCE96C qC6E9C6? |FEF2=’D 56?:2= @7 9:D :?DFC2?46 4=2:> 2E EC:2=]k^Am
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.